Choosing the Best Self-Tanners for a Natural Glow
If you’re looking to achieve that sun-kissed, vacation-ready glow without spending hours in the sun, self-tanners are an excellent solution. Modern formulas have come a long way from the streaky and overly orange options of the past. Today’s self-tanners offer a range of textures and application methods to suit different preferences and lifestyles. Whether you prefer lotions, drops, mousse, or clear tans, there’s something for everyone.
Types of Self-Tanners and Their Benefits
Lotions are ideal for those who want a buildable, low-commitment tan. They can be layered daily and help maintain a spray tan. Drops, on the other hand, allow for more customization, letting you adjust the depth of your glow over a few days. Mousse formulas require a bit more effort but are perfect for events where you want a quick, even tan. Clear mists are great for a soft, subtle glow but need careful blending around the hairline and jaw to avoid streaks.
According to Jess Glaser, a spray tan artist at On The Glow Studio in New York City, “Mousse formulas are best applied the day before a big event. Just make sure you use a mitt and blend carefully, especially around your hands and knuckles.”
How the Testing Was Done
To find the top self-tanners, I tested 20 different products, focusing on their appearance, feel, and wear on the skin. I followed expert advice, applying each product to clean, exfoliated skin using a mitt, gloves, or bare hands as directed. For drops and gradual lotions, I adhered to brand instructions, washing my hands thoroughly after each application and reapplying over several days to build up color. I wore dark, loose clothing post-application and monitored drying time, finish, and transfer.
Each product was rated from one to five based on the following criteria:
- Ease of application: How easy the formula was to work with and whether it blended well.
- Drying time and residue: How quickly the product dried and whether it left a sticky or greasy residue.
- Color result and longevity: How believable the tan looked on light-to-medium skin, how long it lasted, and how evenly it faded.
- Scent: Whether the fragrance was fresh, light, or strong.
- Transfer: Whether the product left stains on clothes or bedding.
Top Picks for 2025
Here are some of the best self-tanners based on the testing:
Best Overall – St. Tropez Self Tan Supreme Violet Bronzing Mousse
This mousse is a favorite for its realistic bronze tone and long-lasting results. It dries quickly and has minimal transfer. However, it may be too dark for very fair-skinned individuals.
Best Budget – St. Moriz Professional Medium Self Tanner Mousse
A vegan, cruelty-free option that delivers impressive results at an affordable price. It’s easy to apply and lasts four to five days.
Best Self-Tanner Drops – Isle of Paradise Self-Tanning Firming Body Drops
These drops mix into your favorite body lotion, allowing for a customizable glow. They are easy to use and provide a natural-looking tan.
Best Drugstore Self-Tanner – Beauty by Earth Self-Tanner
Ideal for dry skin, this gradual lotion has a nourishing texture and no strong scent. It builds slowly over time, resulting in a warm, natural tan.
Best Self-Tanner for Face – Lux Unfiltered No 12 Self-Tanning Face Drops
These face drops are hydrating, fragrance-free, and perfect for sensitive skin. They deliver a natural, even glow without leaving a sticky or greasy finish.
Best Clear Self-Tanner – Tanologist Express Medium Self Tan Water
This water-based formula feels like a lightweight mist and dries quickly. It comes in three shades and offers a natural, streak-free glow.
Best for Travel – Dr. Dennis Gross Alpha Beta Glow Pad Self-Tanner
TSA-friendly and mess-free, these wipes are convenient for on-the-go use. They also contain exfoliating acids to smooth the skin.
Final Thoughts
Self-tanners have evolved significantly, offering a wide range of options for different skin types and preferences. Whether you’re looking for a deep, long-lasting tan or a subtle, natural glow, there’s a product that suits your needs. From budget-friendly options to high-end formulas, the right self-tanner can give you that just-back-from-vacation look without the risk of sun damage.