BBQ: Healthy to Harmful

  • maskobus
  • Jul 24, 2025

Summer in Canada means one thing: barbecue season! From Canada Day celebrations to casual backyard get-togethers, grilling is a beloved tradition. But navigating the tempting array of dishes while staying mindful of your health goals can be a challenge. This guide breaks down some popular barbecue fare, highlighting nutritional strengths and weaknesses to help you build a balanced and enjoyable plate.

Understanding Nutritional Priorities

When evaluating barbecue dishes from a health perspective, several key factors come into play:

  • Protein: Essential for muscle repair, growth, and a feeling of fullness, protein is a valuable component of any meal.
  • Fiber: Crucial for digestive health, regulating blood sugar, and promoting satiety, fiber contributes to overall well-being.
  • Calories: Maintaining a healthy weight and energy balance requires conscious calorie consumption.
  • Saturated Fat: Limiting saturated fat intake is important for cardiovascular health.
  • Net Carbs: Considering net carbs (total carbs minus fiber) is helpful for managing blood sugar levels and energy.
  • Sugar: Excessive sugar consumption can negatively impact metabolic health and increase the risk of various health issues.

Ranking the Classics: From Healthiest to Less Healthy

Here’s a look at how common barbecue dishes stack up, based on a ranking that prioritizes protein and fiber while minimizing calories, saturated fat, net carbs, and sugar:

  1. Slider-Style Mini Burgers
  2. Bacon Cheddar Deviled Eggs (tied with Juiciest Hamburgers Ever)
  3. Boston Baked Beans
  4. Awesome Pasta Salad (tied with Three-Bean Salad)
  5. Summer Corn Salad
  6. The Best Fresh Tomato Salsa (tied with Triple Dipped Fried Chicken)
  7. Unbelievable Chicken
  8. Coconut Shrimp
  9. BBQ Pork
  10. Blackberry Pie
  11. Beer Brats (tied with Red Skinned Potato Salad)
  12. Perfect Summer Fruit Salad
  13. Grilled Corn on the Cob
  14. Classic Macaroni Salad
  15. Alyson’s Broccoli Salad (tied with Sweet Restaurant Slaw)
  16. Corn Dogs
  17. Strawberry Pie
  18. Oven-Baked Baby Back Ribs
  19. Baked Fresh Cherry Pie
  20. Awesome and Easy Corn Casserole
  21. Chef John’s Strawberry Ice Cream (tied with Scrumptious Strawberry Shortcake)
  22. Grandma’s Chocolate Texas Sheet Cake
  23. All American Apple Pie

Keep in mind that these are general rankings, and specific recipes can vary.

Decoding the Data: Nutritional Standouts

Let’s delve deeper into specific nutritional categories to help you make informed choices:

Protein Powerhouses:

  • High in Protein: Triple Dipped Fried Chicken, BBQ Pork, Unbelievable Chicken
  • Low in Protein: The Best Fresh Tomato Salsa, Sweet Restaurant Slaw, Chef John’s Strawberry Ice Cream, Grandma’s Chocolate Texas Sheet Cake, Strawberry Pie, Three-Bean Salad

Fiber Champions:

  • High in Fiber: Boston Baked Beans, Perfect Summer Fruit Salad, Blackberry Pie, Summer Corn Salad
  • Fiber-Free: Bacon Cheddar Deviled Eggs, BBQ Pork, The Best Fresh Tomato Salsa

Calorie Count:

  • High in Calories: Triple Dipped Fried Chicken, Alyson’s Broccoli Salad, All American Apple Pie
  • Low in Calories: The Best Fresh Tomato Salsa, Three-Bean Salad, Grilled Corn on the Cob

Saturated Fat Considerations:

  • High in Saturated Fat: Scrumptious Strawberry Shortcake, Awesome and Easy Corn Casserole, All American Apple Pie, Beer Brats, Chef John’s Strawberry Ice Cream
  • Low in Saturated Fat: Perfect Summer Fruit Salad, The Best Fresh Tomato Salsa, Three-Bean Salad, Blackberry Pie, Boston Baked Beans, Summer Corn Salad, Sweet Restaurant Slaw

Net Carb Content:

  • High in Net Carbs: Triple Dipped Fried Chicken, All American Apple Pie, Perfect Summer Fruit Salad
  • Low in Net Carbs: Bacon Cheddar Deviled Eggs, The Best Fresh Tomato Salsa, Juiciest Hamburgers Ever, Beer Brats

Sugar Levels:

  • High in Sugar: Perfect Summer Fruit Salad, All American Apple Pie, Oven-Baked Baby Back Ribs
  • Low in Sugar: Triple Dipped Fried Chicken, Bacon Cheddar Deviled Eggs, Beer Brats, The Best Fresh Tomato Salsa, Juiciest Hamburgers Ever, Red Skinned Potato Salad, Slider-Style Mini Burgers

Building a Healthier Barbecue Plate: Practical Tips

Here are some strategies to enjoy the barbecue without compromising your health goals:

  1. Pre-Party Fuel: Combat overeating by having a protein- and fiber-rich snack before heading out. Think Greek yogurt with berries or a handful of almonds.

  2. Sauce Savvy: Be mindful of sugary barbecue sauces. Opt for plain grilled meats or explore lighter options like vinegar-based sauces or homemade marinades.

  3. Veggie Vigilance: Don’t assume all vegetable salads are healthy. Creamy dressings can significantly increase saturated fat and calorie content. Seek out options with vinaigrette dressings or enjoy raw vegetables with hummus or Greek yogurt dip.

  4. Hydration Habits: Limit sugary drinks and alcoholic beverages. Alternate with water or sparkling water to stay hydrated and avoid excess calories.

  5. Portion Patrol: Be mindful of portion sizes. Load up on healthier options like grilled vegetables and lean protein, and enjoy smaller portions of richer dishes.

  6. Grill Smart: Grilling lean meats like chicken breast or fish is a healthier alternative to frying. Trimming excess fat from meats before grilling can also reduce saturated fat content.

  7. Homemade Advantage: When possible, bring a healthy dish to share. This ensures you have at least one nutritious option to enjoy. Consider a colourful salad with a light vinaigrette, grilled vegetable skewers, or a fruit platter.

By understanding the nutritional profiles of common barbecue dishes and implementing these simple strategies, you can confidently navigate the summer barbecue scene and enjoy delicious food while staying on track with your health and wellness goals.